5stays selection8.93,480 reviews
Truman Hotel
611 Truman Avenue
From$340 per night
See live prices 🇺🇸 Key West, the USA · Under $400
5 Best Hotels in Key West Under $400
Discover five well-located hotels in Key West that showed dated rates under $400, selected for practical city stays and hotel quality.
Prices checked: Sep 20, 2026
Quick comparison
Reference prices show the intended budget band, not a guaranteed live rate. Confirm the total price and availability on Booking.com for your dates.
Scroll sideways to compare prices and hotel details →
| Hotel | Area | 5stays | Booking.com | Reviews | From |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Truman Hotel | 611 Truman Avenue | 5stays selection | 8.9 | 3,480 | $340 |
| Silver Palms Inn & Historic Homes | 830 Truman Avenue | 5stays selection | 8.8 | 3,418 | $301 |
| The Palms Hotel | 820 White Street | 5stays selection | 8.5 | 2,380 | $342 |
| Blue Flamingo Resort Key West | 3820 North Roosevelt Boulevard | 5stays selection | 8.4 | 1,519 | $302 |
| Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns | 902 Whitehead Street | 5stays selection | 8.4 | 618 | $376 |
A hotel can move above the threshold when demand rises. See how we rank hotels.
5stays selection8.83,418 reviews
Silver Palms Inn & Historic Homes
830 Truman Avenue
From$301 per night
See live prices 
5stays selection8.52,380 reviews
The Palms Hotel
820 White Street
From$342 per night
See live prices 
5stays selection8.41,519 reviews
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West
3820 North Roosevelt Boulevard
From$302 per night
See live prices 
5stays selection8.4618 reviews
Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns
902 Whitehead Street
From$376 per night
See live prices Live availability
Explore more Key West stays under $400
Choose your dates in the map to compare live Booking.com options around Key West.
Prices and availability are supplied inside the Stay22 map and can change with dates, guests and room availability.
Frequently asked questions
Key West hotels under $400: common questions
01Can you get a good hotel in Key West for under $400?
Yes, on lower-demand dates. This page lists five hotels that showed a dated reference rate at or below $400; live availability and final totals can change.
02Which areas of Key West can offer better hotel value?
Compare Old Town, Duval Street, Historic Seaport, Truman Annex and New Town. The best choice depends on the balance of location, transport links and the current nightly total.
03When are Key West hotels usually cheapest?
Lower-demand periods and midweek stays can produce more options, but prices vary with local events, school holidays and room availability.
04Are taxes and extras included in the $400 limit?
Not necessarily. Check the final booking total, taxes, room type, cancellation terms and any mandatory local charges before reserving.
05How far ahead should you book a Key West hotel?
Book once your dates are fixed if the rate and cancellation terms suit you. Recheck live availability close to travel because inventory and prices change.
